📰 Autoimmune 411 Feature Article | By Alice McDonnell

Fasting is everywhere right now.

Everyone seems to be talking about autophagy, longevity, reset days, metabolic magic… and how “you’re only one skipped meal away” from a completely transformed body.

But here’s the real truth — the kind you only learn through:

• decades of autoimmune advocacy, watching thousands of patients try fasting in every possible way

• my own healing journey, starting in my late 30s and early 40s

• and the biology of how autoimmune bodies actually respond to stress

👉 Fasting can absolutely help.
👉 Fasting can absolutely harm.
👉 And the difference has nothing to do with discipline and everything to do with physiology.

Fasting is not “good” or “bad.”
Fasting is a stressor — and stressors heal or flare depending on the state of your terrain.

🌿 A Little Context: Fasting Isn’t New — We Just Forgot Why It Worked

Our ancestors didn’t “fast for autophagy.”
They lived by rhythm — circadian rhythm, seasonal rhythm, and food-availability rhythm.

They:

• ate during daylight

• stopped eating when darkness came

• naturally had overnight fasts much longer than the modern window

• aligned hormones, digestion, and repair cycles with the sun, not the clock

And here’s my favorite reminder:

Breakfast = break-fast.

The idea of “three meals a day” came from:

• industrial schedules

• marketing

• the rise of processed breakfast foods

Our bodies were never designed for constant grazing.

But that doesn’t mean long fasts are ideal for everyone — especially autoimmune patients.

🔬 The Biology: Fasting Is a Stress Signal — Which Can Heal or Harm

When you fast, your body hears:

“Temporary stress detected — initiate adaptation.”

This can trigger:

✨ Hormesis (good stress)
✨ Autophagy (cellular cleanup)
✨ Improved insulin sensitivity
✨ Lower inflammation in some cases
✨ Metabolic flexibility

But in an autoimmune or inflamed body, fasting can also cause:

⚠️ Cortisol spikes
⚠️ Thyroid suppression
⚠️ Blood sugar crashes
⚠️ Anxiety or heart-racy sensations
⚠️ Increased inflammatory signaling
⚠️ Post-fast crashes

This is why two people can do the same protocol and have completely different outcomes.

Autoimmune bodies have unique stress tolerances.

🧬 About Autophagy: The Most Misunderstood Buzzword in Wellness

People often fast solely for autophagy — the cell-cleaning process.

But here’s the important truth:

👉 Autophagy can be triggered many ways beyond fasting.

Including:

• exercise

• red light therapy

• saunas

• cold exposure

• sleep

• nutrient timing

• AMPK activation

Fasting is one option, not the only one — and often not the best for dysregulated thyroid, adrenals, or blood sugar.

✨ My Story: When Fasting Worked Beautifully… and When It Didn’t

When I first did AIP years ago, I began with a 3-day fast through Dr. Kharrazian’s metabolic reset approach.

I felt fantastic.
My body was younger, my stress load was lighter, and my mitochondria were more resilient.

But now?

My physiology is different.
My hormones are different.
My stress load is different.
My autoimmune picture is different.

Today, I no longer tolerate long fasts well — and that is normal.

Biology evolves.
What served you in one season may stress you in another.

🌞 My Preferred Approach Today: Rhythm Over Restriction

I personally follow a gentle rhythm:

• natural overnight fasting

• eating within a daytime window

• no extreme restrictions

• no cortisol rollercoasters

• no white-knuckling hunger

This approach honors biology:

🌅 Daytime → digestion, energy, activity
🌙 Night → melatonin, repair, autophagy

Gentle rhythms often work far better for autoimmune bodies than aggressive protocols.

⚠️ When Fasting May Not Be Ideal

Fasting tends to backfire when someone has:

• thyroid issues

• adrenal dysfunction

• hypoglycemia

• chronic anxiety

• insomnia

• high inflammation

• traumatic stress/patterns

• severe fatigue

These individuals often feel worse, not better.

🌿 When Fasting May Help

Gentle fasting can support:

• insulin sensitivity

• digestive rest

• metabolic flexibility

• mitochondrial function

• cellular cleanup

• inflammation balance

But only if the terrain is ready.

🔑 How to Explore Fasting Safely (The Autoimmune 411™ Way)

If you want to experiment with fasting, here is a gentle, biology-first approach:

🌅 1. Start with circadian rhythm

Stabilize:

• morning sunlight

• sleep

• protein-rich meals

• hydration + minerals

A regulated circadian system makes fasting smoother and safer.

🍽 2. Begin with an easy overnight fast

Most people naturally hit 12 hours.
If that feels good:

→ try 12.5 hours
→ then 13
→ then maybe 14

Move slowly.
No pressure. No pushing.

🧪 3. Expand only if your body gives green lights

Good signs:
✔ steady energy
✔ good sleep
✔ calm nervous system
✔ stable thyroid symptoms

Red flags:
⚠️ anxiety
⚠️ palpitations
⚠️ shakiness
⚠️ headaches
⚠️ cold extremities
⚠️ flare symptoms

If a red flag appears → shorten the window again.

🥗 4. Make nourishment your priority

Autoimmune healing requires:

• protein

• minerals

• stable glucose

• mitochondrial support

If fasting leads to under-eating, it will always work against you.

🔄 5. Remember: the goal is metabolic flexibility, not maximal fasting

A body that feels safe, nourished, and rhythmically aligned will naturally:

• improve autophagy

• improve insulin sensitivity

• lower inflammation

• regulate hormones

You don’t need extreme protocols — just biological alignment.

🧭 Autoimmune 411 Takeaway

Fasting is not a badge of honor.
It’s a tool — and like all tools, it works only when the foundation is ready.

Your terrain determines your tolerance.

Your biology determines your timing.

Your nervous system determines your healing window.

And your season of life determines what your body can handle right now.

That’s my slow take on fasting.

 👣 Want the full, step-by-step SMART Path™ with protocols, lab guides, and sequencing tools?
Inside Autoimmune 411 Academy, I walk you through every phase of the SMART Path™—so you’ll know exactly whatto do, when to do it, and how to adapt it to your body. No more guessing, no more overwhelm—just a clear, proven pathway.
[→ Enroll Here]

💪 On the Frontlines with you,
Alice McDonnell
Founder and 20+ Year Veteran Patient Advocate
Autoimmune 411 ~ Hashimoto’s 411 ~ Autoimmune 411 Academy

🚨 Disclaimer: I’m not a medical professional. I’m sharing what I’ve learned through over two decades of research, lived experience, patient advocacy, and feedback. This is for informational purposes only—always consult your healthcare provider before making changes to your health plan.